New Resources - Critical Thinking
Check out the latest resource: Debater's Guide to Elements and Standards of Thought
Provincial Results
All Divisions - E.C. Leslie Debate Tournament
Provincials - Social Justice
Saskatoon Home Educated Debaters and Walter Murray Collegiate Institute Debate Club
At Walter Murray Collegiate Institute, Saskatoon
March 17, 2018
Resolutions:
Rounds 1 & 2 Prepared Topic
This House would make poverty a significant mitigating factor in criminal prosecutions.
Round 3 Impromptu Topic
This House believes that juries should be abolished in criminal trials.
Round 4 Impromptu Topic
Elementary: This House believes we should celebrate International Women's Day.
High School: This House believes that affirmative action policies are counterproductive.
Results
Elementary Beginner
Top Teams: Byron Merkosky Team Award
- Salma E./Maham Z., Regina Huda School
- Sahasro B./Lucas T., Silverspring School
- Isabelle M./ Bryn H., Caswell School
Top Speakers: Speaker Award
- Anne K., Greystone Heights School
- Rita A., Sylvia Fedoruk School
- Aiman I., Regina Huda School
Elementary Intermediate
Top Teams: Melville District Credit Union Award
- Will S./Elliot C., Saskatoon Home Educated Debaters
- Abiha M./Yusra N., Regina Huda School
- Maria C./Elsa L., Saskatoon Home Educated Debaters
Top Speakers: Assinibioa S.D. #69 Speaker's Cup
- Will S., Saskatoon Home Educated Debaters
- Sam F., Caswell School
- Maria C., Saskatoon Home Educated Debaters
Special Award
Michael Misanchuk Award of Excellence (Top Saskatoon Elementary Intermediate Team):
Will S./Elliot C., Saskatoon Home Educated Debaters
High School Novice
Top Teams: Right Honourable John G. Diefenbaker Centre Award
- Jemmie P./Megan D., Swift Current Comprehensive High School
- Swarna E./Brianna A., Evan Hardy Collegiate
- 3. Umama R./Alejandra V., Winston Knoll Collegiate
Top Speakers: Leader Post Award
- Darshana L., Walter Murray Collegiate
- Megan D., Swift Current Comprehensive High School
- 3. Ishita M., North Battleford Comprehensive High School
High School Open - Results of Open Final
Top Teams: Schumiatcher Award
- Anwyn D./Afsoneh A., Walter Murray Collegiate
- Mohammed A./Ben J., Walter Murray Collegiate
- 3. Wardah M./Graeme S., Campbell Collegiate
Top Speakers: E.C. Leslie Award
- Anwyn D., Walter Murray Collegiate
- Wardah M., Campbell Collegiate
- Graeme S., Campbell Collegiate
Open Grade 9
Top Team: Husky Oil Award
Kaia B./Bhavandeep B., Walter Murray Collegiate
Top Speaker: Melville Comprehensive Award
Kaia B., Walter Murray Collegiate
Special Awards
Saskatoon Home Educated Debaters Spirit of Debate Award:
Each club was asked to select their recipients. A committee of the SEDA Board of Directors then selected the top recipient based on the submitted write-ups of each recipient.
Top Elementary Recipient
Liam B., Saltcoats School
Elementary Recipients
Ben S., Elsie MIronuck Community School
Marcus F., Saskatoon Home Educated Debaters
Nada E. Saskatoon Misbah School (Sylvia Fedoruk School)
Rohan N. Sylvia Fedoruk School
Katherine C., Greystone Heights School
Liam B., Saltcoats School
Top High School Recipient
Swarna E., Evan Hardy Collegiate
High School Recipients
Trinity A., Carlton Comprehensive High School
Muhammed A., Walter Murray Collegiate
Swarna E., Evan Hardy Collegiate
Hamza E., Regina Huda School
Sarah C., Saskatoon Home Educated Debaters
Megan D., Swift Current Comprehensive High School
Chan Min R., Luther College High School
SEDA Youth Volunteer Award
Wardah M., Campbell Collegiate
2018 E.C. Leslie Provincial Debate Championships RESULTS
Beginner
Rank
Name
W/L
Ind. Ave
Team Ave.
1
Salma E.
4
80.67
80.42
1
Maham Z.
4
80.17
80.42
2
Sahasro B.
3
81.74
81.09
2
Lucas T.
3
80.43
81.09
3
Isabelle M.
3
81.96
79.98
3
Bryn H.
3
78.00
79.98
4
Frida S.
3
79.67
79.53
4sabelle Mementary
Miette M.
3
79.39
79.53
5
Sophia H.
3
78.50
79.00
5
Kaitlyn C.
3
79.50
79.00
6
Magnus I.
3
80.28
78.59
6
Bilal A.
3
76.89
78.59
7
Lauren C.
2
79.63
81.02
7
Anne K.
2
82.42
81.02
8
Ayesha A.
2
79.69
80.97
8
Rita A.
2
82.26
80.97
9
Laraib M.
2
78.71
80.46
9
Aiman I.
2
82.21
80.46
10
Louis-Pascal D.
2
80.00
77.92
10
Isen Y.
2
75.83
77.92
11
Habiba A.
1
81.13
79.69
11
Rachel P.
1
78.25
79.69
12
Vivek N.
1
79.71
79.21
12
Max C.
1
78.71
79.21
13
Aurora K.
1
79.33
78.54
13
Lucas C.
1
77.75
78.54
14
Alaa I.
1
77.58
78.42
14
Eesha Q.
1
78.25
78.42
15
Ayaan K.
1
77.17
77.83
15
Ryan A.
1
78.50
77.83
2018 E.C. Leslie Provincial Debate Championships RESULTS
Intermediate
Rank
Name
W/L
Ind. Ave
Team Ave.
1
Will S.
4
82.67
82.00
1
Elliot C.
4
81.33
82.00
2
Abiha M.
3
80.25
79.96
2
Yusra N.
3
79.67
79.96
3
Maria C.
3
81.42
79.90
3
Elsa L.
3
78.38
79.90
4
Blake K.
3
76.67
79.31
4sabelle Mementary
Sam F.
3
81.96
79.31
5
Alex J.
3
76.71
78.23
5
Dishita E.
3
79.75
78.23
6
Zaid I.
3
78.25
77.44
6
Tahir Z.
3
76.63
77.44
7
Laraib W.
3
77.13
77.19
7
Aamina T.
3
77.25
77.19
8
Huda A.
2
80.00
80.69
8
Fatima A.
2
81.38
80.69
9
Nada E.
2
80.29
80.50
9
Rohan N.
2
80.71
80.50
10
Katherina C.
2
79.67
79.71
10
Arnica K.
2
79.75
79.71
11
Fatima E.
2
78.13
79.50
11
Muhammad M.
2
80.88
79.50
12
Grayson L.
2
80.33
78.50
12
Ty D.
2
76.67
78.50
13
Abdur-raafay H.
2
75.50
77.31
13
Ali E.
2
79.13
77.31
14
Isabelle E.
2
76.78
75.89
14
Charlotte L.
2
75.00
75.89
15
Keegan I.
1
80.04
78.73
15
Zaiden O.
1
77.42
78.73
16
Jerry Y.
1
76.21
77.19
16
Krishna N.
1
78,17
77.19
17
Liam B.
1
79.75
77.10
17
Ayden B.
1
74.46
77.10
18
Abby S.
1
78.33
77.06
18
Ryder G.
1
77.78
77.06
19
Mikayla U.
1
79.92
77.02
19
Zainab S.
1
74.13
77.02
20
Kevin L.
1
74.63
76.31
20
Rafay A.
1
78.00
76.31
21
Mikhail S.
1
74.78
74.98
21
Tim Y.
1
75.17
74.98
22
Nick R.
0
73.04
74.42
22
Zhi R.
0
75.79
74.42
2018 E.C. Leslie Provincial Debate Championships RESULTS
Novice
Rank
Name
W/L
Ind. Ave
Team Ave.
1
Jemmie P.
4
76.71
79.47
1
Megan D.
4
82.23
79.47
2
Swarna E.
3
81.00
80.67
2
Brianna A.
3
80.33
80.67
3
Umama R.
3
78.67
79.67
3
Alejandra V.
3
80.67
79.67
4
Bridget S.
2
82.35
81.01
4sabelle Mementary
Darshana L.
2
79.67
81.01
5
Abby D.
2
73.25
77.06
5
Jarrod Q.
2
80.88
77.06
6
Ishita M
1
82.17
77.86
6
Vikas M.
1
73.56
77.86
7
Janna E.
1
74.89
76.11
7
Hamza E.
1
77.33
76.11
E.C. Leslie Provincial Debate Championships RESULTS
Open
Rank
Name
W/L
Ind. Ave
Team Ave.
1
Anwyn D.
4
85.63
84.34
1
Afsoneh A.
4
83.06
84.34
2
Mohammed A.
4
81.19
80.15
2
Ben J.
4
79.10
80.15
3
Wardah M.
3
84.06
83.59
3
Graeme S.
3
83.13
83.59
4
Nathan G.
3
82.56
82.22
4sabelle Mementary
Mueez R.
3
81.89
82.22
5
Hussain A.
3
79.71
80.88
5
Yangming H.
3
82.04
80.88
6
Miriam C.
3
80.52
79.01
6
Cheran F.
3
77.50
79.01
7
Kaia B.
2
82.75
80.33
7
Bhavandeep B.
2
77.92
80.33
8
Sarah K.
2
80.00
79.88
8
Elizabeth D.
2
79.75
79.88
9
Nohl P.
2
82.58
79.73
9
Ria B
2
76.88
79.73
10
Victor W.
2
80.96
78.92
10
Aditya K.
2
76.88
78.92
11
Gabriela C.
2
76.63
78.60
11
Luke S.
2
80.58
78.60
12
January D.
2
79.11
78.31
12
Magda M.
2
77.50
78.31
13
Harshini A.
2
78.92
78.02
13
Eljay D.
2
77.13
78.02
14
Seth N.
1
77.33
79.54
14
Carrick P.
1
81.75
79.54
15
Sarah C.
1
76.65
77.59
15
Jarica G.
1
78.54
77.59
16
Kevin Z.
1
76.56
77.22
16
William L.
1
77.88
77.22
17
Rowan F.
1
77.38
76.58
17
Jules O.
1
75.79
76.58
18
Mantaqua C.
1
76.35
76.48
18
Aroba K.
1
76.60
76.48
19
Taegan I.
1
76.71
75.88
19
Dante B.
1
75.04
75.88
20
Zona I.
0
78.33
78.17
20
Ammara S.
0
78.00
78.17